CRYPTO VENTURE COHORT V0.3.2B TOKEN JUDGE EVIDENCE REPAIR

Cohort ID: CPV031-20260816215626-66d636b2 GraphRun: 10 Raw protocols generated: 20 Raw Sol theses: 20. Onchain passed: 11. Onchain rejected: 9. Token design attempts: 11. Token design skipped: 9. Token unnecessary: 1. Token optional/routed SaaS: 4. Token strongly justified: 1. Token essential: 0. Duplicates: 0. Crypto survivors: 0. Autonomous crypto survivors: 0. Assisted high-potential: 0. Security-blocked: 0. Finalists: 0. Generation attempts: 20

Runtime

{
  "raw_theses": 20,
  "raw_target": 20,
  "raw_generated": 20,
  "raw_sol_theses": 20,
  "requested_protocol_count": 20,
  "generation_attempts": 20,
  "accepted_protocols": 20,
  "duplicate_rejections": 0,
  "token_necessity_rejections": 0,
  "generation_sources": [
    "sol"
  ],
  "model_usage": {
    "sol_generation_requests": 20,
    "sol_onchain_judge_requests": 20,
    "sol_protocol_architecture_requests": 11,
    "sol_token_design_requests": 11,
    "sol_token_utility_judge_requests": 11,
    "sol_final_ic_requests": 6,
    "qwen_requests": 0
  },
  "sol_generation_requests": 20,
  "sol_onchain_judge_requests": 20,
  "fallback_count": 0,
  "onchain_rejected": 9,
  "onchain_passed": 11,
  "crypto_survivors_after_onchain": 11,
  "token_design_skipped_due_to_onchain_rejection": 9,
  "token_unnecessary_rejections": 1,
  "token_optional_route_to_saas": 4,
  "token_essential": 0,
  "token_strongly_justified": 1,
  "serious_crypto_survivors": 0,
  "crypto_survivors": 0,
  "token_design_attempts": 11,
  "token_design_count_matches_onchain_passed": true,
  "sol_token_design_requests": 11,
  "sol_token_utility_judge_requests": 11,
  "crypto_novelty_removed": 0,
  "hard_exclusion_rejections": 0,
  "regeneration_attempts": 0,
  "regenerated_protocols": 0,
  "unfilled_slots_after_regeneration": 14,
  "regeneration_policy": "V0.3.1 uses total raw Sol generation budget; offchain or weak token ideas are not force-filled.",
  "crypto_light_research_seconds": 0.0,
  "crypto_light_research_sources": 0,
  "crypto_light_research_rejected_sources": 0,
  "research_insufficient_count": 0,
  "research_survivors": 0,
  "protocol_security_gate_blocked": 0,
  "protocol_security_gate_passed": 0,
  "token_red_team_failures": {
    "TOKEN_NOT_REQUIRED": 5,
    "YIELD_DEPENDENCY": 1,
    "SLASHING_DEPENDS_ON_HUMAN_JUDGMENT": 1
  },
  "token_red_team_count": 6,
  "sol_token_red_team_requests": 0,
  "top5_deep_research_count": 0,
  "top5_research_coverage_before": {},
  "top5_research_coverage_after": {},
  "crypto_ranked_count": 0,
  "crypto_top_3_count": 0,
  "autonomous_crypto_survivors": 0,
  "assisted_high_potential": 0,
  "finalists": 0,
  "sol_final_ic_requests": 6,
  "qwen_requests": 0,
  "human_legal_gate_count": 0,
  "legal_review_required": true,
  "corrected_existing_six_researched": 6,
  "corrected_existing_six_red_team": 6,
  "corrected_existing_six_final_ic": 6,
  "corrected_research_sources": 85,
  "corrected_research_rejected_sources": 193,
  "corrected_token_red_team_failures": {
    "TOKEN_NOT_REQUIRED": 6,
    "YIELD_DEPENDENCY": 1,
    "SLASHING_DEPENDS_ON_HUMAN_JUDGMENT": 1
  },
  "v032b_existing_six_token_judge": 6,
  "v032b_existing_six_red_team": 6,
  "v032b_existing_six_final_ic": 6,
  "v032b_before_after_classifications": [
    {
      "company": "Agent Passport Clearinghouse",
      "before": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "after": "TOKEN_UNNECESSARY",
      "score": 18.0,
      "required_field_gaps": [],
      "final_ic_decision": "REJECT_TOKEN_NOT_NEEDED",
      "final_ic_score": 62.3
    },
    {
      "company": "PatchBond Network",
      "before": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "after": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "score": 48.0,
      "required_field_gaps": [],
      "final_ic_decision": "REJECT_TOKEN_NOT_NEEDED",
      "final_ic_score": 66.4
    },
    {
      "company": "ProofGrid Compute Attestation Network",
      "before": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "after": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "score": 42.0,
      "required_field_gaps": [],
      "final_ic_decision": "REJECT_TOKEN_UTILITY_WEAK",
      "final_ic_score": 63.6
    },
    {
      "company": "ProofBond",
      "before": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "after": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "score": 54.0,
      "required_field_gaps": [],
      "final_ic_decision": "REJECT_TOKEN_UTILITY_WEAK",
      "final_ic_score": 64.3
    },
    {
      "company": "Compute Clearance Network",
      "before": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "after": "TOKEN_STRONGLY_JUSTIFIED",
      "score": 78.0,
      "required_field_gaps": [],
      "final_ic_decision": "PROTOCOL_VALIDATE",
      "final_ic_score": 79.7
    },
    {
      "company": "ProofGrid Compute Escrow",
      "before": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "after": "TOKEN_OPTIONAL",
      "score": 58.0,
      "required_field_gaps": [],
      "final_ic_decision": "REVISE_TOKEN_MODEL",
      "final_ic_score": 67.9
    }
  ],
  "v032b_required_field_gaps": 0,
  "v032b_token_red_team_failures": {
    "TOKEN_NOT_REQUIRED": 5,
    "YIELD_DEPENDENCY": 1,
    "SLASHING_DEPENDS_ON_HUMAN_JUDGMENT": 1
  }
}

Model Usage

{
  "sol_generation_requests": 20,
  "sol_onchain_judge_requests": 20,
  "sol_protocol_architecture_requests": 11,
  "sol_token_design_requests": 11,
  "sol_token_utility_judge_requests": 11,
  "sol_final_ic_requests": 6,
  "qwen_requests": 0
}

Ranking

Top 3

Fewer than 3 qualified; weak token ideas were not promoted.

V0.3.2B Before/After

Agent Passport Clearinghouse: TOKEN_OPTIONAL -> TOKEN_UNNECESSARY. Score: 18.0. Final IC: REJECT_TOKEN_NOT_NEEDED at 62.3. Required field gaps: none Final rationale: The protocol has real collateral and slashing needs, but those needs are not native-token-specific. ETH, USDC, tokenized cash instruments, or insurance-backed collateral can economically reproduce the security model while improving price stability, liquidity, and institutional acceptance. The native token mainly adds captive value capture and bootstrapping optionality, not an essential protocol-specific property.
PatchBond Network: TOKEN_OPTIONAL -> TOKEN_OPTIONAL. Score: 48.0. Final IC: REJECT_TOKEN_NOT_NEEDED at 66.4. Required field gaps: none Final rationale: PatchBond has real collateral and slashing needs, but the protocol-specific property is not strong enough to make a native token necessary. The core security function is an enforceable vendor bond with independent assessment and predictable payout conditions, which USDC, ETH, fiat escrow, bank guarantees, or insurance collateral can reproduce more credibly for enterprise procurement. Although removing the token moderately degrades bootstrapping, native provider admission, and treasury value capture, external collateral is preferable because buyers value payout certainty, liquidity, accounting simplicity, and legal enforceability more than native-token reflexive security.
ProofGrid Compute Attestation Network: TOKEN_OPTIONAL -> TOKEN_OPTIONAL. Score: 42.0. Final IC: REJECT_TOKEN_UTILITY_WEAK at 63.6. Required field gaps: none Final rationale: TOKEN_OPTIONAL because the native token may help bootstrap and coordinate a portable attestation network, but the core security model does not require it. ETH, USDC, or approved external collateral is preferable because slashing needs predictable, liquid, widely accepted value, while the protocol-specific properties such as machine identity, verifier reputation, routing eligibility, and dispute records can be represented as protocol state backed by external bonds. Any degradation from removing the token is mainly loss of endogenous value capture and bootstrap alignment, not loss of the attestation or slashing function itself.
ProofBond: TOKEN_OPTIONAL -> TOKEN_OPTIONAL. Score: 54.0. Final IC: REJECT_TOKEN_UTILITY_WEAK at 64.3. Required field gaps: none Final rationale: ProofBond has real collateral and slashing needs, but the protocol-specific property claimed for the native token can be reproduced economically enough with ETH, USDC, or other external collateral. Portable machine reputation, verifier staking, dispute slashing, provider admission, and routing priority can all be implemented using external collateral plus non-transferable machine credentials and contract-enforced penalties. Although removing the native token causes moderate degradation in endogenous alignment, fee capture, and bootstrapping flexibility, ETH and especially USDC are preferable for the core guarantee because they are more liquid, more legible to buyers, less volatile, and provide clearer compensation value when claims fail.
Compute Clearance Network: TOKEN_OPTIONAL -> TOKEN_STRONGLY_JUSTIFIED. Score: 78.0. Final IC: PROTOCOL_VALIDATE at 79.7. Required field gaps: none Final rationale: The token is strongly justified but not essential. The protocol-specific property that cannot be reproduced economically enough with ETH, USDC, or generic external collateral is the combination of persistent bonded machine identity, reputation-linked earning capacity, risk-proportional native lockup, and slashing that recapitalizes a protocol-native security budget. External collateral can reproduce financial penalties, but it does not create the same endogenous accountability layer where compute capacity, routing, verification, and machine reputation are all secured by stake whose value and opportunity cost are tied to the network itself.
ProofGrid Compute Escrow: TOKEN_OPTIONAL -> TOKEN_OPTIONAL. Score: 58.0. Final IC: REVISE_TOKEN_MODEL at 67.9. Required field gaps: none Final rationale: TOKEN_OPTIONAL because ProofGrid has real token-shaped utility, but the protocol-specific property is not impossible to reproduce economically enough with ETH, USDC, or external collateral. The essential functions are slashable bonds, verifier accountability, machine reputation, routing priority, and security-budget funding; these can be implemented with stablecoin or ETH collateral while keeping reputation and machine identity native to the protocol database or contracts. A native token may moderately improve alignment, bootstrapping, and identity stickiness, but USDC or ETH is preferable because it gives buyers predictable collateral value, deeper liquidity, simpler compensation, and lower reflexive security risk despite some degradation in network-specific alignment.

Routed To SaaS

PatchBond Network: TOKEN_OPTIONAL V0.3.2B strict token judge evidence repair; native token not sufficiently justified versus ETH/USDC/external collateral.
ProofGrid Compute Attestation Network: TOKEN_OPTIONAL V0.3.2B strict token judge evidence repair; native token not sufficiently justified versus ETH/USDC/external collateral.
ProofBond: TOKEN_OPTIONAL V0.3.2B strict token judge evidence repair; native token not sufficiently justified versus ETH/USDC/external collateral.
ProofGrid Compute Escrow: TOKEN_OPTIONAL V0.3.2B strict token judge evidence repair; native token not sufficiently justified versus ETH/USDC/external collateral.

V0.2 Comparison

{
  "v02": {
    "raw": 30,
    "crypto_survivors": 2,
    "autonomous_survivors": 0,
    "finalists": 0
  },
  "v03": {
    "raw": 20,
    "onchain_rejected": 5,
    "onchain_passed": 15,
    "token_unnecessary": 12,
    "token_optional": 3,
    "crypto_survivors": 0,
    "finalists": 0
  },
  "v031_corrected": {
    "raw": 20,
    "onchain_passed": 11,
    "onchain_rejected": 9,
    "token_optional": 6,
    "crypto_survivors": 0,
    "finalists": 0
  },
  "v032b": {
    "token_optional": 4,
    "token_unnecessary": 1,
    "token_strongly_justified": 1,
    "token_essential": 0,
    "crypto_survivors": 0,
    "finalists": 0
  }
}

Token Red Team Failures

{ "TOKEN_NOT_REQUIRED": 5, "YIELD_DEPENDENCY": 1, "SLASHING_DEPENDS_ON_HUMAN_JUDGMENT": 1 }

Research Health

{ "broad_research_redone": false }

Token Utility Distribution

{}

Capability Gaps

[]

Stop condition: no token sale, no NFT sale, no Founding Membership sale, no fundraising, no mainnet issuance, no investor/user contact, no liquidity pool, no market making, no real spend.

12 KiB Raw Blame History