h3-blackwell-runtime/research/vortex_exact_attention/HARDWARE_CAPABILITIES.md

84 lines
4.2 KiB
Markdown
Raw Normal View History

# Hardware Capabilities
## Interpretation Rule
Blackwell-native means using target-specific scheduling, state ownership, or
data movement supported by the target. Compiling the SM89 algorithm for
`sm_121a` is not sufficient. SM100, SM120, and SM121 are separate schedules.
## Capability Matrix
| Capability | SM100 / B200 | SM120 / RTX PRO 6000 | SM121 / GB10 |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Compute capability | 10.0 | 12.0 | 12.1 |
| TMA global/shared tensor copies | Documented | Documented | Documented |
| Native matrix programming model | `tcgen05.mma` with TMEM | warp-level `mma.sync` | SM120-family warp-level `mma.sync` |
| Programmer-visible TMEM | Yes | Not exposed | Not exposed |
| Native UMMA/tcgen05 INT8 | Exposed | Not exposed | Not exposed |
| Sage-compatible INT8 path | `tcgen05.kind::i8` can be investigated | supported classic INT8 `mma.sync` | supported classic INT8 `mma.sync` |
| FP8 PV path | `tcgen05` FP8 forms | warp-level FP8 `mma.sync` | warp-level FP8 `mma.sync` |
| Hopper WGMMA | Not a portable target path | Not a target path | CUDA 13 rejects for `sm_121a` |
| Registers per SM / max per thread | 64K / 255 | 64K / 255 | 64K / 255 |
| Shared memory per SM / block | 228 / 227 KiB | 100 / 99 KiB | 100 / 99 KiB |
| Maximum resident warps | 64 | 48 | 48 |
| Maximum resident threads | 2048 | 1536 | 1536 |
The public SM120/121 Blackwell MMA interface does not expose a Sage2-compatible
UMMA INT8 QK operation. Exact SM121 work therefore retains the supported INT8
`mma.sync` arithmetic while making TMA staging, role scheduling, ownership, and
handoff Blackwell-specific. FP8/FP4 QK would define `vortex_fast`, not
`vortex_exact`.
## SM121 Facts From Retained Evidence
- The current 128-thread kernel uses 255 registers/thread and 32 KiB dynamic
shared memory.
- Two CTAs provide eight resident warps, approximately `16.67%` of the 48-warp
ceiling.
- A 168-register cap reaches three CTAs but spills catastrophically; compiler
lifetime cleanup is not enough.
- CUDA 13 rejects `wgmma.fence`, `wgmma.mma_async`, `wgmma.commit_group`, and
`wgmma.wait_group` for `sm_121a`.
- CUTLASS 4.6 executes SM120-family block-scaled narrow MMA on GB10, but that is
not an exact replacement for Sage2 INT8 QK.
- TMA producer/consumer scheduling is available, but role-specific register
redistribution, named-barrier cost, and concurrent INT8/FP8 issue must be
measured rather than assumed.
## Required Capability Probes Before Prototype
1. Compile empty 256- and 320-thread role-specialized CTAs; record per-thread
registers, aggregate register allocation, occupancy, and spill traffic.
2. Test whether any supported register-allocation control can give producer and
consumer warps different practical budgets on SM121.
3. Measure one-CTA residency at 48, 52, 56, 64, and 68 KiB shared memory.
4. Measure TMA plus named-barrier two-slot handoff for 4 and 8 KiB payloads.
5. Verify simultaneous INT8 QK and FP8 PV warps produce actual overlap in pipe
counters, not merely alternating aggregate utilization.
6. Establish thread-block cluster/DSM support, placement, simultaneous
residency, and remote shared-memory latency on GB10 before accepting VEA-C.
7. Record sustained clocks and power behavior for 128-, 256-, and 320-thread
CTAs.
## Portability Policy
- SM121 is first and must compile specifically for `sm_121a`.
- SM120 may share API and contract code, but requires its own geometry,
resource model, profiler evidence, and acceptance gates.
- SM100 should use a separate `tcgen05`/TMEM design. Porting the SM121 register
accumulator schedule unchanged would discard the principal SM100 capability.
## Sources
- NVIDIA CUDA GPU Compute Capability: https://developer.nvidia.com/cuda-gpus
- CUDA Programming Guide: https://docs.nvidia.com/cuda/cuda-programming-guide/
- PTX ISA: https://docs.nvidia.com/cuda/parallel-thread-execution/
- CUTLASS Blackwell functionality:
https://github.com/NVIDIA/cutlass/blob/main/media/docs/cpp/blackwell_functionality.md
- CUTLASS `mma_sm100_umma.hpp`, `mma_sm120.hpp`, and architecture config.
- Local measurements: `SAGE2_BLACKWELL_DESIGN.md` and retained P0/post-FC2 NCU
reports.
Documented API support does not establish throughput, latency, queue depth, or
bit identity. Those remain target-specific measurements.